A Practical Guide for Hogwarts House Sorting


Collage by Kellie

I’m an obsessive person. When I like something, I like it so hard that every person even remotely tangential to me or my life is affected by it. Part of this stems from my inherent desire to understand everything, to categorize and analyze and…well, sort. But you’ve read the title, so you know where I’m going with this.

Tumblr is a cool place where people who like things get together to like them together without scaring each other away, and one cool thing that people on Tumblr seem to love –so much– is sorting characters from not-Harry Potter into Hogwarts houses. I do it, too! It’s fun! But it can also be incredibly aggravating when somebody sorts one of your favorite characters into the wrong house. So today, I have created a practical guide to sorting your favorite characters into houses.

To begin, let me state that sorting is less about personality than it is about values. But why? Because Harry didn’t want to be in Slytherin. Because Harry WANTED to be brave – because he values bravery. Hermione could easily have been in Ravenclaw, and Ron in Hufflepuff, but they weren’t. Because, like LeAnn Rhymes, sorting is ALL about values!

Gryffindor is a house characterized by seemingly antiquated ideals of chivalry, but don’t let that trick you into thinking every Gryffindor is old fashioned. Gryffindors place value on honor and bravery and daring, but that does not mean that every Gryffindor is necessarily honorable or brave or rash. How else could Neville Longbottom, Cormac McLaggen, Minerva McGonagall, and Percy Weasley even have been in the same house? And what about Wormtail? The thing that connects these characters, though, is that they admire and aspire to bravery above all else. You can be smart or loyal or cunning and still wish to be brave. And that’s what matters.

Hufflepuff is for LOSERS. Lol jk, it’s actually a pretty sweet house, and thanks to Pottermore’s equalizing powers, its reputation has improved quite a bit over the past year. As JK Rowling’s daughter once put it, Hufflepuff is the house that everyone SHOULD want to be in. Because above all, Hufflepuffs value loyalty, respect, trust, and that crazy thing called love. It’s why Tonks, one of the bravest and smartest witches in the HPverse, was a Hufflepuff. Because it is love and family and loyalty that she values most. It’s why she never used her powers as a metamorphmagus to look like Fleur, okay. To thine own self be true. And that’s the word.

Ravenclaws are like, real smart – but not always conventionally so. Take everybody’s favorite airhead for example – Ms. Luna Lovegood. Why did JK Rowling choose to depict the most prominent Ravenclaw in the series as a space cadet? Because Ravenclaw is not about book smarts. Ravenclaw is about the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake, about curiosity, about falling in love with the world around you and wanting to know everything about it. Luna is intelligent, of course, but more than that, she is curious. She’s also brave and loyal and cunning and a million other things, but that’s not what motivates her; it’s her fascination with people and places and things that makes her distinctly Luna. 

Slytherin is for evil people who do evil things because they love being evil and shit. Except it’s completely not even like that at all. The thing about Slytherins is that they’re ultimately always going to be looking out for themselves (and, to a degree, their immediate families). It’s why Narcissa Malfoy stopped at nothing to protect Draco. It’s why so many Slytherins are for the enslavement of muggles and the lowering of the status of half-bloods and mudbloods. Because Slytherin is about Otherness. When you remove the concept of Slytherin from the context of Harry Potter, though, Slytherin just becomes a fancy metaphor for “hipster” or “elite academic” or “generally ambitious person.” Let me reiterate – bravery, loyalty, intelligence, and ambition are not mutually exclusive values. While Slytherins place the HIGHEST value on ambition and personal recognition, that does not mean that they cannot also be brave and intelligent and loyal.

So I hope we all learned a super cool lesson here today. Maybe the next time you want to sort your favorite characters into Hogwarts houses, you’ll stop to think about what motivates their actions and drives their characters before you start to list off personality traits.

Seacrest out.


About Taylor Brogan

Managing Editor - inconnu magazine. Tweets @thbrogan.


  1. AnAbundanceOfApples

    Have you been sorted on Pottermore?

    • I was sorted into Gryffindor on Pottermore, after having lived most of my adolescent life thinking I was a Ravenclaw. FOOLISH GIRL, I WAS. You?

      • AnAbundanceOfApples

        I was hoping for Gryffindor, but thought I’d probably get sorted into Hufflepuff. I was wrong :P I’m also in Gryffindor!

  2. AnAbundanceOfApples

    Awesome post, btw :)

  3. Yes, so true.. I agree completely. I hate it when people say Slytherins are bad, or Hufflepuffs are losers. I guess they never truly understood the sorting hat’s words.

  4. Pingback: A Practical Guide for Hogwarts House Sorting | Taylor Brogan

  5. anonymous

    I don’t think the pottermore sorting hat is accurate enough. You get asked a few random questions and thats it? Dont get me wrong, I do like some of the questions… But it does not really get to who you are. I saw a page online that linked Hogwarts houses with a person’s Myer-Briggs personality type.
    You’d have to know you’re Myer-Briggs type by doing a good test online (best way is to answer lots of questions and be honest), then compare your type to your ideal Hogwarts house. The page is called:
    “The Sorting Hat of Harry Potter and Myer-Briggs Personality Typology.”
    I think its the most accurate sorting thing Ive seen so far.

    I know a lot of people have a favorite house or they think/want to be in a particular house… However thats not necessarily how it works. You have to be open-minded and honest about it. Also all the houses are equal. There is no housevthat is better than another because they all have positive and negative traits.



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: